Workers Comp Audits for Contractors Who Pay Subs

How to Keep 1099 Subcontractor Payments Off Your Workers Comp Audit

Last reviewed by Garrett Amundsen, Chief Operating Officer (NPN 21727795)

Short answer. Your carrier reconciles the payroll you estimated against the payroll it finds, and every payment to a subcontractor who cannot prove their own workers comp for the dates you paid them is treated as your payroll and billed at your class rate. A 1099 does not change that. What keeps those payments off the audit is a certificate for every sub dated to cover every payment, verification with the carrier that the policy was in force, the state's exemption document for owner-only subs, and all of it in one file before the auditor asks. TradeGuard Compliance does that work for you and is built to deliver a penalty-free audit, a lower premium, and your time back. Call (913) 689-5474 or book a demo below.

What the auditor is actually looking for

A certificate for every sub you paid, dated to cover the payments.

The test applied at audit is whether you can show the sub was insured under their own workers comp policy for the dates you paid them. A certificate issued after the job, or one whose policy period starts after your first check, does not cover those payments. Collect it before the first check and again at the sub's renewal.

Proof the policy was actually in force, not just that a certificate exists.

A certificate is a snapshot on the day it was issued. A sub can hand you one and cancel the policy the next week. Carrier verification, direct with the sub's insurer and repeated through the term, is what turns a piece of paper into evidence that holds up when the auditor checks.

The state-specific document for subs who are exempt.

An owner-only sub may have no employees to insure. Each state has a document for that case, and the auditor wants it in the file: the Kansas affidavit of exempt status, the Florida certificate of exemption, the Texas joint agreement, the Ohio BWC certificate on the sub's elective coverage, or in Missouri a certificate on an owner-excluded policy. The state sections below say which.

One file, in the order the auditor reads it.

Payments by sub, the certificate or exemption document that covers each payment date, and the verification record. The Missouri Division of Workers' Compensation puts the burden where it sits: the contractor's own policy “will dictate how premium would be calculated, what records are needed to compute the premium, and the audit of the records relating to the policy.”

Why the carrier can charge you for someone else's workers

Every state in which TradeGuard operates makes the contractor above a subcontractor liable for that sub's workers when the sub has not insured them. The carrier that insures you is pricing that liability. When your file shows the sub secured its own coverage, the liability is not yours and the premium goes away; when it does not, the auditor has no choice. The statutes differ in wording and in what document they expect, so the state sections below are the checklist.

Missouri

  • The Division of Workers' Compensation answers the GC's question directly. If a sub is uninsured, “the insurance company for the general contractor may be required to pay claims, and, as a result, will charge premium for that uninsured subcontractor.” The GC “needs to provide proof to its insurance carrier that the sub or independent contractor has secured its own workers' compensation obligations to avoid paying premium.”
  • The Department of Commerce and Insurance adds that the charge applies even when the sub has no employees: the GC's insurer “will charge additional premium if you cannot provide proof of coverage, even if you have no employees AND provide proof that you (as an owner) are also covered under the policy.” An owner-excluded minimum-premium policy on the sub, with its certificate, is the usual proof. See workers comp ghost policies in Missouri.
  • The liability behind the charge is RSMo 287.040: an independent contractor “shall be deemed to be the employer of the employees of his subcontractors and their subcontractors,” and no contractor up the chain is liable “if the employee was insured by his immediate or any intermediate employer.”

Kansas

  • K.S.A. 44-503(g) is the GC's protection and the auditor's checklist in one sentence. The principal is not liable for a subcontractor's workers when the sub has secured compensation “as evidenced by a current certificate of workers compensation insurance,” and “no insurance company shall charge a principal a premium for workers compensation insurance for any liability for which the contractor has secured the payment of compensation.” No current certificate in the file, no protection from the charge.
  • For a self-employed sub with no employees, 44-503(a) says a worker “shall not include an individual who is a self-employed subcontractor,” and K.S.A. 44-5,127 provides the Kansas Insurance Department's notarized affidavit of exempt status, which “shall establish a rebuttable presumption that the executor is not an employee.” The Department's form is good for that job or similar jobs for one year from the date of notary. Keep the signed affidavit with the payments it covers. See workers comp ghost policies in Kansas.

Texas

  • Texas writes the audit rule into the statute. Once a hiring contractor and an independent contractor file a joint agreement under Labor Code 406.145, “an insurance company may not require the payment of an insurance premium by a hiring contractor for coverage of an independent contractor or an independent contractor's employee, helper, or subcontractor.” The agreement is on the commissioner's form, filed with the Division, and applies to each hiring agreement between the two for one year.
  • The alternative is the 406.144 coverage agreement, under which the hiring contractor withholds the cost of coverage from the contract price and covers the independent contractor under its own policy. TDI's guide notes you can buy workers comp specifically because “you employ contractors who don't have workers' compensation.” Either agreement belongs in the audit file next to the sub's payments. See workers comp ghost policies in Texas.

Florida

  • Florida Statutes 440.10(1)(c): “A contractor shall require a subcontractor to provide evidence of workers' compensation insurance. A subcontractor who is a corporation and has an officer who elects to be exempt as permitted under this chapter shall provide a copy of his or her certificate of exemption to the contractor.” The Division says contractors must make certain all subs have coverage before work begins.
  • The reason is 440.10(1)(b): the contractor “shall be liable for, and shall secure, the payment of compensation to all such employees, except to employees of a subcontractor who has secured such payment,” and 440.02(18)(c)2 makes everyone paid by a construction contractor as a subcontractor an employee unless validly exempt or covered. Exemption certificates are valid two years, so the file has to track their expiration dates too. See workers comp ghost policies in Florida.

Ohio

  • ORC 4123.01 treats every person in the service of an independent contractor or subcontractor “who has failed to pay into the state insurance fund” as “the employee of the person who has entered into a contract” with that contractor. BWC then adjusts your premium at true-up “for the difference between estimated gross payrolls and actual gross payrolls” under 4123.35.
  • The only document is the sub's own BWC Certificate of Ohio Workers' Compensation, which exists for an owner-only sub only if that owner elected coverage with BWC.

Where the file usually leaks

  • The certificate was collected at onboarding and never again, so the renewal date passed mid-job and the second half of the payments are uncovered.
  • The certificate is real but the policy was cancelled for non-payment a month later, and nobody checked with the carrier.
  • The owner-only sub gave you a certificate on a general liability policy, not workers comp, and nobody read the form.
  • The sub signed the affidavit, joint agreement or exemption for last year's job and you kept paying them this year.
  • The documents exist, in email threads and a shared drive, and assembling them for the auditor takes a week your team does not have.

None of these is a legal problem; each is a documentation problem that becomes a premium charge because the document was not where it needed to be on the day it was needed.

How TradeGuard Compliance runs this for you

  1. You send us your trade partner list. We reach out to every sub, collect certificates, W-9s, licenses and agreements, and chase the ones who do not respond by email, text and phone.
  2. We verify each policy directly with the carrier, because a certificate alone does not prove coverage, and we re-verify through the policy term so a cancellation is caught while the sub is on your job, not at your audit.
  3. A sub without coverage can get a quote and bind a policy through TradeGuard Insurance inside the onboarding flow, including the owner-only policy on the state pages above, so the gap closes instead of sitting in a spreadsheet.
  4. Every document, verification and conversation is logged with a timestamp. When the auditor asks, the file is one click: every sub, every certificate or exemption document, every verification, in order.
  5. You see where every sub stands and do none of the chasing. It is a service, month to month, alongside whatever broker writes your own coverage.

One client's $30,000 workers comp audit charge went to $0 once every sub's coverage was documented and verified. Another was spending four to five hours a week tracking certificates before handing it to us. The full service, pricing model and the questions GCs ask are on TradeGuard Compliance for general contractors. If the sub needs the policy first, every state's owner-only rules are on workers comp ghost policies and the state pages linked above. TradeGuard Insurance is a licensed insurance agency (NPN 22154473) based in Leawood, Kansas.

Send Your Sub List. Get an Audit File Instead of an Audit Bill.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Yes, and it does, whenever you cannot show the sub was insured under their own policy for the dates you paid them. A 1099 does not settle it; proof of the sub's own coverage does. The Missouri Division of Workers' Compensation says the GC's insurer will charge premium for an uninsured subcontractor and that the GC must give its carrier proof the sub secured its own coverage to avoid it. Kansas puts the same rule in K.S.A. 44-503(g): no premium may be charged to a principal for liability the subcontractor has secured, as evidenced by a current certificate. TradeGuard Compliance is built to deliver the audit where that proof is already in the file for every sub, which is how one client's $30,000 audit charge went to $0.

Only if the policy was actually in force on the dates you paid the sub. A certificate is a snapshot on the day it was issued; the sub can cancel the policy the next week and the certificate still looks fine. Auditors apply the test by date, so what holds up is a certificate whose policy period covers the payment dates plus verification with the carrier that the policy stayed active. TradeGuard Compliance verifies directly with the carrier and re-verifies through the term for exactly that reason.

It depends on the state, and the auditor wants the state's document in your file. In Missouri the usual answer is a certificate on an owner-excluded minimum-premium policy, because the Department of Commerce and Insurance says the GC's insurer charges for an uninsured sub even if the sub has no employees. In Kansas a self-employed sub can sign the Insurance Department's notarized affidavit of exempt status under K.S.A. 44-5,127, good for one year with you. In Texas you and the sub can file a joint agreement under Labor Code 406.145, after which your insurer may not charge you premium for that sub. In Florida an exempt officer or LLC member hands you a copy of their certificate of exemption under 440.10(1)(c), and a construction sole proprietor is an employee by statute. In Ohio the sub needs a BWC certificate, which exists only if they elected coverage.

Proof that the sub has secured its own workers comp obligations, so your carrier does not charge you for the sub. The Division of Workers' Compensation says your own policy dictates how premium is calculated, what records are needed and how the audit is run, so the practical answer is a certificate for each sub dated to cover each payment, and for an owner-only sub a certificate on their owner-excluded policy. The liability behind it is RSMo 287.040, under which you are deemed the employer of your subcontractors' employees unless they were insured by the sub.

Yes, by statute. Labor Code 406.145(g) says that once a hiring contractor and an independent contractor have filed a joint agreement, an insurance company may not require the hiring contractor to pay premium for coverage of that independent contractor or their employees, helpers or subcontractors, other than under a 406.144 coverage agreement. The joint agreement applies for one year from filing to each hiring agreement between you, unless a later agreement says otherwise, so it has to be refiled and kept with the payments it covers.

For the exempt officer or member named on it, yes: Florida Statutes 440.10(1)(c) says a subcontractor whose officer has elected exemption shall provide a copy of the certificate of exemption to the contractor. It does not cover the sub's employees or any non-exempt owner, who need a Florida policy, and it expires two years from issue. Your file needs the exemption certificates, their expiration dates, and a certificate of insurance for any sub with employees.

Under ORC 4123.01 the people working for that sub are treated as your employees, and under 4123.35 BWC adjusts your premium for the difference between the payroll you estimated and the payroll it finds, with the balance due immediately. The only proof is the sub's own BWC Certificate of Ohio Workers' Compensation, and for an owner-only sub that certificate exists only if the owner elected coverage with BWC.

We collect each sub's certificate and documents before they start, verify the policy directly with the carrier, re-verify through the term, log every document and verification with a timestamp, and keep the file current as subs renew, lapse or change. At audit it is one click: every sub, every certificate or exemption document, every verification, in order. The service is built to deliver a penalty-free audit, a lower premium and your team's time back, and clients report it replaces four to five hours a week of certificate tracking. It is month to month and works alongside your current broker.

Sources

Every legal statement on this page traces to one of these primary sources. The date is when we last read the text at that address.

  1. Missouri Division of Workers' Compensation FAQ: my general contractor says I need to provide proof of coverage

    A GC can require proof from a sole proprietor subcontractor because its insurer charges premium for uninsured subcontractors.

    Checked

  2. Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, Workers' Compensation FAQs

    How premium is priced (NCCI class codes), the owner payroll basis by year, experience rating thresholds, premium adjustments, and the contractor proof-of-coverage answer.

    Checked

  3. Missouri Division of Workers' Compensation, Workers' Compensation Requirements for the Missouri Construction Industry (WC-259, 05-25)

    An LLC must carry coverage even if all employees are members; the GC's insurer charges additional premium when a subcontractor cannot show proof of coverage.

    Checked

  4. RSMo 287.040, Liability of employer, contractors, subcontractors

    The independent contractor is deemed the employer of its subcontractors' employees; no liability up the chain if the employee was insured by the immediate or an intermediate employer.

    Checked

  5. K.S.A. 44-503, Subcontracting

    Principal contractor liability for a subcontractor's workers, and relief where the subcontractor has secured compensation shown by a current certificate.

    Checked

  6. K.S.A. 44-5,127, Affidavit of exempt status

    The affidavit creates a rebuttable presumption that the signer is not an employee and does not affect the signer's own employees.

    Checked

  7. Kansas Insurance Department, Affidavit of Exempt Status Under the Workers Compensation Act (Revised 5/2022)

    The notarized affidavit an independent contractor gives a hiring contractor; good for that job or similar jobs for one year from the date of notary.

    Checked

  8. Texas Labor Code 406.141 to 406.146, Coverage of certain building and construction workers

    Independent contractor definition, the written agreement under which a hiring contractor provides coverage for an independent contractor (406.144), and the joint agreement declaring the subcontractor an independent contractor (406.145).

    Checked

  9. Texas Department of Insurance, Workers' compensation insurance guide

    Texas does not require most private employers to carry coverage; contractors with government entities must; you must have at least one employee to buy a policy, though some insurers cover executive officers with no other employees; buy only from TDI-licensed companies.

    Checked

  10. Florida Statutes 440.02, Definitions

    A sole proprietor or partner engaged in the construction industry is an employee (18)(c)4; subcontractors paid by a contractor are employees unless validly exempt or covered (18)(c)2; construction corporations may exempt no more than three officers who each own at least 10 percent (18)(b)2.

    Checked

  11. Florida Statutes 440.10, Liability for compensation

    A contractor is liable for the employees of an uninsured subcontractor, shall require evidence of coverage from subcontractors, and an exempt officer of a subcontractor must provide a copy of the certificate of exemption.

    Checked

  12. Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Workers' Compensation, Coverage Requirements

    Construction employers with one or more employees, including owners who are corporate officers or LLC members, must have coverage; contractors must confirm subcontractor coverage before work begins.

    Checked

  13. Ohio Revised Code 4123.01, Definitions

    A sole proprietorship, partnership or individual incorporated as a corporation may elect to include the owner as an employee by written notice to the bureau; no benefits until the bureau receives the notice. Workers of an independent contractor who has not paid into the state insurance fund are the employees of the person who hired that contractor.

    Checked

  14. Ohio Revised Code 4123.35, Payment of premiums by employers; self-insurance

    Every private employer pays its premium into the state insurance fund; the bureau provides written proof of coverage.

    Checked